Best of Draft Cube

[Thomas David Baker]

A cube of the best common and uncommon draft picks from the last 22 sets. Here's what we have so far.

What do you think?

Lists particularly in need of review by people who know what they are doing are: ROE, COK, BOK, SOK, LRW, MOR, GPT, DIS, 5DN.

# ROE Beastbreaker of Bala Ged Brimstone Mage Corpsehatch Dawnglare Invoker Domestication Enclave Cryptologist Flame Slash Forked Bolt Hada Spy Patrol Heat Ray Joraga Treespeaker Last Kiss Narcolepsy Nirkana Cutthroat Oust Pelakka Wurm Smite Staggershock Vendetta Wall of Omens # WWK Bestial Menace Calcite Snapper Cunning Sparkmage Leatherback Baloth Loam Lion Refraction Trap Searing Blaze Tideforce Elemental Tomb Hex Vapor Snare # ZEN Baloth Woodcrasher Burst Lightning Disfigure Gatekeeper of Malakir Grazing Gladehart Hideous End Inferno Trap Journey to Nowhere Kor Skyfisher Living Tsunami Marsh Casualties Merfolk Seastalkers Plated Geopede Punishing Fire River Boa Shepherd of the Lost Torch Slinger Trusty Machete Vampire Nighthawk Vines of Vastwood	# M10 Air Elemental Armored Ascension Blinding Mage Cudgel Troll Doom Blade Dragon Whelp Fireball Goblin Artillery Harm's Way Howl of the Night Pack Lightning Bolt Merfolk Looter Mind Control Overrun Pacifism Pyroclasm Serra Angel Sleep Tendrils of Corruption # ARB Behemoth Sledge Bituminous Blast Bloodbraid Elf Enlisted Wurm Esper Stormblade Marisi's Twinclaws Qasali Pridemage Slave of Bolas Terminate Vengeful Rebirth # CFX Ember Weaver Esper Cormorants Grixis Slavedriver Parasitic Strix Path to Exile Sedraxis Alchemist Shambling Remains Viashino Slaughtermaster Volcanic Fallout Wild Leotau # ALA Agony Warp Branching Bolt Bull Cerodon Executioner's Capsule Fatestitcher Infest Jund Charm Knight of the Skyward Eye Magma Spray Naya Charm Necrogenesis Oblivion Ring Resounding Thunder Rhox Charger Rhox War Monk Sprouting Thrinax Tower Gargoyle Vithian Stinger Wild Nacatl Woolly Thoctar	# EVE Ballynock Trapper Cankerous Thirst Desecrator Hag Hatchet Bully Noggle Bandit Puncture Blast Savage Conception Snakeform Unmake Wickerbough Elder # SHM Biting Tether Boggart Ram-Gang Burn Trail Devoted Druid Firespout Grief Tyrant Hungry Spriggan Incremental Blight Kitchen Finks Kulrath Knight Mistmeadow Witch Murderous Redcap Plumeveil Prison Term Rune-Cervin Rider Seedcradle Witch Silkbind Faerie Spectral Procession Torrent of Souls Trip Noose # MOR Boldwyr Intimidator Meadowboon Obsidian Battle-Axe Rivals' Duel Spitebellows Stonybrook Schoolmaster Swell of Courage Thornbite Staff Violet Pall War-Spike Changeling # LRW Briarhorn Changeling Berserker Cloudgoat Ranger Crib Swap Dreamspoiler Witches Eyeblight's Ending Final Revels Goldmeadow Harrier Imperious Perfect Knight of Meadowgrain Lash Out Makeshift Mannequin Marsh Flitter Mulldrifter Nameless Inversion Neck Snap Shriekmaw Tarfire Thundercloud Shaman Warren Pilferers	# FUT Arc Blade Foresee Gathan Raiders Ichor Slick Imperiosaur Infiltrator il-Kor Kavu Primarch Nacatl War-Pride Spin into Myth Sprout Swarm # PLC Calciderm Shaper Parasite Necrotic Sliver Deadwood Treefolk Shade of Trokair Harmonize Pyrohemia Dead / Gone Enslave Stonecloaker # TSP Basalt Gargoyle Brine Elemental Careful Consideration Castle Raptors Crookclaw Transmuter Durkwood Baloth Errant Ephemeron Firemaw Kavu Griffin Guide Looter il-Kor Nightshade Assassin Riftwing Cloudskate Spiketail Drakeling Sporesower Thallid Strangling Soot Sudden Death Sulfurous Blast Temporal Isolation Tromp the Domains Weatherseed Totem
# GPT Blind Hunter Electrolyze Gelectrode Mortify Pillory of the Sleepless Repeal Savage Twister Thunderheads Wee Dragonauts Wildsize # DIS Condemn Guardian of the Guildpact Leafdrake Roost Minister of Impediments Plumes of Peace Rakdos Guildmage Rakdos Ickspitter Rise / Fall Sky Hussar Wrecking Ball # RAV Belltower Sphinx Boros Guildmage Carven Caryatid Compulsive Research Drooling Groodion Faith's Fetters Galvanic Arc Greater Mossdog Keening Banshee Lightning Helix Mark of Eviction Moldervine Cloak Moroii Oathsworn Giant Putrefy Selesnya Guildmage Shambling Shell Trophy Hunter Vedalken Dismisser Watchwolf	# SOK Captive Flame Death Denied Ghost-Lit Raider Hail of Arrows Hand of Cruelty Hand of Honor Manriki-Gusari O-Naginata Rushing-Tide Zubera Stampeding Serrow # BOK Genju of the Cedars Genju of the Falls Genju of the Fields Genju of the Spires Horobi's Whisper Matsu-Tribe Sniper Ninja of the Deep Hours Okiba-Gang Shinobi Shimmering Glasskite Throat Slitter # COK Befoul Cage of Hands Distress Ghostly Prison Hanabi Blast Hideous Laughter Hinder Kabuto Moth Kami of Ancient Law Kitsune Blademaster Mystic Restraints Nezumi Graverobber No-Dachi Otherworldly Journey Pull Under Rend Flesh Ronin Houndmaster Sakura-Tribe Elder Samurai of the Pale Curtain Sensei's Divining Top	# 5DN Cranial Plating Devour in Shadow Eternal Witness Furnace Whelp Grafted Wargear Loxodon Anchorite Magma Jet Sunburst Manta Vedalken Mastermind Vulshok Sorcerer # DST Barbed Lightning Chittering Rats Juggernaut Leonin Battlemage Leonin Bola Loxodon Mystic Nemesis Mask Skullclamp Test of Faith Vulshok Morningstar # MIR Aether Spellbomb Barter in Blood Betrayal of Flesh Blinding Beam Bonesplitter Crystal Shard Grab the Reins Icy Manipulator Isochron Scepter Leonin Skyhunter Lightning Greaves Loxodon Warhammer Mask of Memory One Dozen Eyes Predator's Strike Pyrite Spellbomb Slith Firewalker Terror Thirst for Knowledge Viridian Shaman	# Fixing Akoum Refuge Graypelt Refuge Jwar Isle Refuge Kazandu Refuge Sejiri Refuge Rupture Spire Arcane Sanctum Crumbling Necropolis Jungle Shrine Savage Lands Seaside Citadel Azorius Chancery Boros Garrison Dimir Aqueduct Golgari Rot Farm Gruul Turf Izzet Boilerworks Orzhov Basilica Rakdos Carnarium Selesnya Sanctuary Simic Growth Chamber Azorius Signet Boros Signet Dimir Signet Golgari Signet Gruul Signet Izzet Signet Orzhov Signet Rakdos Signet Selesnya Signet Simic Signet

[Thomas David Baker]

Updated with Kieran's suggestions for LRW/MOR ...

LRW: +Final Revels +Thundercloud Shaman, -Changeling Hero -Changeling Berserker
MOR: +Swell of Courage +Rivals' Duel, -Moonglove Changeling -Festercreep

[Ben Titmarsh]

How about Neck Snap and Dreamspoiler Witches for Lorwyn

[Kieran Symington]

You've got Nacatl War-Pride and Nacatl Hunt-Pride mixed up - your Future Sight list currently has a Conflux card in it!

[Thomas David Baker]

Replacing? I heard that Neck Snap was not as good in LRW as the equivalent M10 card. But feel free to correct me.

Ben Titmarsh said:

How about Neck Snap and Dreamspoiler Witches for Lorwyn

[Ben Titmarsh]

I'd replace Wren's Run Vanquisher and Burrenton Forge Tender. Wren's isn't strong without elf Tribal, and BFT isn't exactly first pick material, more sideboard after thought.

Thomas David Baker said:

Replacing? I heard that Neck Snap was not as good in LRW as the equivalent M10 card. But feel free to correct me.

Ben Titmarsh said:

How about Neck Snap and Dreamspoiler Witches for Lorwyn

[Thomas David Baker]

Sounds good.

LRW: +Neck Snap, Dreamspoiler Witches; -Wren's Run Vanquisher, Burrenton Forge-Tender
FUT: -Nacatl Hunt-Pride; +Nacatl War-Pride

Ben Titmarsh said:

I'd replace Wren's Run Vanquisher and Burrenton Forge Tender. Wren's isn't strong without elf Tribal, and BFT isn't exactly first pick material, more sideboard after thought.

Thomas David Baker said:

Replacing? I heard that Neck Snap was not as good in LRW as the equivalent M10 card. But feel free to correct me.

Ben Titmarsh said:

How about Neck Snap and Dreamspoiler Witches for Lorwyn

[Thomas David Baker]

We seem to have a disagreement about Changeling Titan and Changeling Berserker. Can we cut Thundercloud Shaman (no Giants!) and have them both?

[Dan Barrett]

I agree, it loses all it's first-pickable value when there aren't loads of other giants, whereas things like Imperious Perfect still have a lot of value.

Thomas David Baker said:

We seem to have a disagreement about Changeling Titan and Changeling Berserker. Can we cut Thundercloud Shaman (no Giants!) and have them both?

[ross miles]

i'm not convince halimar wavewatch is good enough either. is it there to have enough blue cards?

[Paul Hodgson]

Are there enough instants to make dreamspoiler worth it? I'm guessing "probably", although most of it's power came from flashing in dudes during your opponent's attack step, removing a 1 toughness attacker or depowing something bigger to allow for an uneven trade. Without a significant number of flash dudes you won't have mana available for shenanigans as you'll have to run men out to keep board parity.

I'd say Hornet Harasser is a better option, has a bit of synergy with the warren pilferers and can trade up with opposing 4/4s.

Also, why is makeshift mannequin not in there, that card is ridiculous...

Wavewatch is ok, slows down aggro and then gets big/huge later on, tho Hada Spy Patrol might be better overall?

[Kieran Symington]

You should replace Halimar Wavewatch with Hada Spy Patrol - it's much better at the early levels.

Berserker over Titan seems good now I think about it. I'd like to keep Thundercloud Shaman because he still hits for a point even with no other giants, though I'm probably outvoted on that one.

[Thomas David Baker]

ROE: -Halimar Wavewatch, +Hada Spy Patrol.
LRW: -Changeling Titan, +Changeling Berserker.

Dreamspoiler Witches is much better than Hornet Harrasser when you live the dream which makes me want to keep the Witches in. Perhaps the dream will not be lived much. Anyone else want to vote for Harrasser?