Magic: the Gathering in the UK
Constructed League Season Four - Elder Dragon Highlander
Demonic Tutor Constructed Leagues do not take place at set times. Instead they are played whenever two (or more) players from the league can get together. They are slightly formalized versions of casual games with a bit more at stake.
Here are the rules for Season Four which will be in the Elder Dragon Highlander format.
- Generals will be known from the start of the league.
- Post your general in this thread or send it to bakert@gmail.com if you want it to remain secret until others have submitted.
- You may alter your deck (within the rules) at any time between matches.
- Match results should be reported on the dedicated results thread on demonictutor.ning.com
- Matches up to and including Friday 18th December will be included in the points total. You may begin playing as soon as your general is submitted.
- Any number of proxies are allowed. They must be full-size versions of the cards not simply names or altered basic lands. They can be color or black and white. (If you don't have access to a printer and need some proxies let me know.)
- The competition is being played for glory only. There is no entry fee or prizes but Wizards Play Network cards will be awarded for participation. It's 100% upside.
- Matches may contain any number of players (at least 2!) Players may play each other as many times as they like.
- Matches should be played until only one player remains unless a time limit is agreed beforehand. A game may be played to any time limit agreed by all participants (for example, "until Jason announces the draft starting").
- We will try and arrange a four-player game involving the four players with the highest points total at the end of the season. If this isn't possible the final table topper will be declared the winner. The judge's decision is final.
- The competition will use the deck construction and game rules found here: http://www.dragonhighlander.net/rules.php
- In addtion the following cards are outright-banned not just suggested-banned:
Amulet of Quoz
Ancestral Recall
Balance
Biorhythm
Black Lotus
Bronze Tablet
Chaos Orb
Coalition Victory
Contract from Below
Darkpact
Demonic Attorney
Falling Star
Fastbond
Gifts Ungiven
Grindstone
Jeweled Bird
Karakas
Kokusho, the Evening Star
Library of Alexandria
Limited Resources
Lion's Eye Diamond
Metalworker
Mox Emerald
Mox Jet
Mox Pearl
Mox Ruby
Mox Sapphire
Panoptic Mirror
Protean Hulk
Rebirth
Recurring Nightmare
Shahrazad
Sway of the Stars
Tempest Efreet
Time Vault
Time Walk
Timmerian Fiends
Tinker
Upheaval
Worldgorger Dragon
Yawgmoth's Bargain
- Additionally, the following cards may not be used as a General:
Braids, Cabal Minion
- Mulligans are "Partial Paris" (see http://www.dragonhighlander.net/rules.php).
- Points will not be awarded win/lose as in previous constructed leagues but rather according to the rules below.
- Printable version of points awards
- A player claiming a points award must do so before the end of the turn when the condition is met and must indicate to all players that they are claiming the award. Players may also point out points awards for other players. Each award may only be claimed once per game, unless stated otherwise.
-2 Points
Chasm: Destroy or Remove all lands in play through spells or abilities. (This penalty is in the spirit of the rule, and not the letter of the rule, effects that would reset the board for all or most of the players at the table will be awarded this penalty. This can be awarded to the same player more than once per pod.)
-1 Point
Greedy McGreederson: Per extra turn taken. Can be awarded more than once.
+1 Point
123s: Resolve the third spell that’s converted mana cost is the third number in a row. Player A plays Mogg Fanatic (CMC 1) then Vexing Shusher (CMC 2), then Player B resolves Volcanic Fallout (CMC 3) Player B would be awarded this. If Player C then casts Chameleon Colossus, Player C would get an extra point for following this pattern, and each successive spell resolving in an increasing fashion would awarded 1 point.
Better Late Than Never: First player to resolve the second version of a creature already in play. It must be the exact same card as the first (copies and Clones don’t count).
Blackjack: Control two creatures whose total power is exactly 21. May be awarded for a specific creature pair only once per pod (A creature that leaves play and comes back is a different creature).
Block Party: Have a permanent in play or spell present on the stack from each set of any block. The blocks are Ice Age, Invasion, Kamigawa, Lorwyn-Shadowmoor, Masques, Mirage, Mirrodin, Odyssey, Onslaught, Ravnica, Shards of Alara, Tempest, Time Spiral, Urza. (Basic Lands from those sets do not count.)
Copycat: First player to have a spell or permanent copied by an opponent.
Déjà vu: Be the first player to have a card put on top your library from the battlefield, graveyard or the stack by an opponent.
Double Take: First player to control two functionally identical non-token creatures with different names. Creatures must have the same power, toughness, converted mana cost and all abilities (such as Grizzly Bears and Balduvian Bears), but not necessarily color (such as Prodigal Sorcerer and Prodigal Pyromancer). This will awarded only when the stack is empty. (Copies and Clones don’t count).
Edge of Disaster: First player to have fewer than five cards in his or her library.
Enhanced Interrogation Techniques: Cause a creature to be sent to the Graveyard by means of -1/-1 counters.
First Blood: First player to have a creature killed by an opponent. Kill includes destroy, exile, or cause a player to sacrifice the creature. Combat damage doesn’t count. (This can be awarded to multiple people if they all have creatures killed at the same time by the same effect – Wrath of God, Damnation, etc…)
Fourth Times the Charm: Resolve your General 4 times in a single game from the Command Zone.
Generalissimo: Kill a player with General damage. Can be awarded more than once.
Getting to Basics: Control at least 7 Basic Lands.
Good Samaritan: Intentionally cause an opponent to gain 10+ life in one shot (getting your Beacon of Immortality redirected doesn’t count for you, but for the person who redirected it).
Hey, That’s Mine: First player to have a permanent stolen (exchanges don’t count).
Hot Potato: Redirect any portion of non combat damage directed at you to another opponent.
I’m Cool Too: Second player to kill a creature he or she doesn’t control. Kill includes destroy, exile, or cause a player to sacrifice the creature. Combat damage doesn’t count.
I’m Probably Next: Have the lowest life total, which must be lower than 10 when the first player is killed.
Just Enough: Deal exactly lethal non-General damage to a player who is at 7 or more life.
Let’s Do That Again: Save an opponent from taking lethal damage. (This can be through prevention or redirection of damage, whether it be direct or from creatures, or through the use of life gaining spells or abilities. This award can only be earned once per opponent saved, multiple saves of the same opponent by the same person do not count.)
Look at Me: Last person standing in a pod.
Lucky 13: Have a single creature deal exactly 13 combat damage to a player at once. May be awarded for an individual creature only once per pod. (A creature that leaves play and comes back is a different creature).
Overkill: Deal 40+ more damage to a player than is required to kill them.
Salsa Dancer: Cast the fifth spell on a single stack; cannot be awarded in the same stack as Flamenco Dancer.
Start with the Top: Destroy or Exile a Sensei’s Divining Top you don’t control.
Straight: Control at least one creature of five consecutive powers (for example, Mogg Fanatic, Jackal Pup, Mogg Flunkies, Ravenous Baloth, Shivan Dragon). This will be awarded only when the stack is empty. This may only be awarded to an individual player once per pod, although it may be awarded to multiple players.
Taste the Rainbow: Sacrifice five total different creatures in one turn. Of those creatures you must sacrifice a creature for each color of your General. Multicolored creatures can be sacrificed for this, but will have to choose what color they are being sacrificed for.
That Was Rude: First player to have a spell countered by another player’s spell or ability.
What Goes Around: Take control of a permanent that an opponent took control of from another opponent.
+2 Points
Cramped Quarters: Control at least 40 different non-token permanents with the stack empty.
Three’s Not a Crowd: Resolve three different non-land permanents of three different types on the same turn. This may only be awarded to an individual player once per pod, although it may be awarded to multiple players. (Non-land permanent types are Artifact, Creature, Enchantment, and Planeswalker. Resolving a spell that is any combination of permanent types will count as one or the other, not both. Example: Enigma Sphinx is an Artifact Creature; you must choose whether it will count for your Artifact or your Creature for this award.)
You’re Outta Here: Kill a player or being directly responsible for a player’s death. There is the obvious – controlling the source of the damage (whether it’s direct or creatures). This also includes, although is not limited to alternate methods, such as controlling the Howling Mine that makes the player deck himself, or redirecting lethal damage to someone. (Player A plays Fireball, Player B Swerves the Fireball to Player C.) This can be awarded more than once to the same player.
+3 Points
ABCs: Resolve the third spell that starts with a third consecutive letter, one additional point to a player who continues the chain. For example Player A plays Storm Herd, Player B casts Terminate then Unsummon. Player B gets 3 points. Player C then plays Venser and gets 1 Point. Player B then plays Withered Wretch and gets 1 point. Player D casts Wrath of God, therefore breaking the chain.
Flush: Control five non-token creatures of EXACTLY the same color (five Green creatures, or Green and Red creatures, but not three Green and 2 Green and Red). This will be awarded only when the stack is empty. This may only be awarded to an individual player once per pod, although it may be awarded to multiple players.
Flamenco Dancer: Cast the eighth spell on a single stack, cannot be awarded in the same stack as Salsa Dancer.
Straight Flush: Control five creatures of exactly the same color(s) in five consecutive powers. This will be awarded only when the stack is empty. This may only be awarded to an individual player once per pod, although it may be awarded to multiple players.
+4 Points
Bases Loaded: Control a Land, Creature, Enchantment, Artifact, and Planeswalker, while having both a Sorcery and an Instant present on the stack.
Short Version
Here are the rules for Season Four which will be in the Elder Dragon Highlander format.
- Generals will be known from the start of the league.
- Post your general in this thread or send it to bakert@gmail.com if you want it to remain secret until others have submitted.
- You may alter your deck (within the rules) at any time between matches.
- Match results should be reported on the dedicated results thread on demonictutor.ning.com
- Matches up to and including Friday 18th December will be included in the points total. You may begin playing as soon as your general is submitted.
- Any number of proxies are allowed. They must be full-size versions of the cards not simply names or altered basic lands. They can be color or black and white. (If you don't have access to a printer and need some proxies let me know.)
- The competition is being played for glory only. There is no entry fee or prizes but Wizards Play Network cards will be awarded for participation. It's 100% upside.
- Matches may contain any number of players (at least 2!) Players may play each other as many times as they like.
- Matches should be played until only one player remains unless a time limit is agreed beforehand. A game may be played to any time limit agreed by all participants (for example, "until Jason announces the draft starting").
- We will try and arrange a four-player game involving the four players with the highest points total at the end of the season. If this isn't possible the final table topper will be declared the winner. The judge's decision is final.
- The competition will use the deck construction and game rules found here: http://www.dragonhighlander.net/rules.php
- In addtion the following cards are outright-banned not just suggested-banned:
Amulet of Quoz
Ancestral Recall
Balance
Biorhythm
Black Lotus
Bronze Tablet
Chaos Orb
Coalition Victory
Contract from Below
Darkpact
Demonic Attorney
Falling Star
Fastbond
Gifts Ungiven
Grindstone
Jeweled Bird
Karakas
Kokusho, the Evening Star
Library of Alexandria
Limited Resources
Lion's Eye Diamond
Metalworker
Mox Emerald
Mox Jet
Mox Pearl
Mox Ruby
Mox Sapphire
Panoptic Mirror
Protean Hulk
Rebirth
Recurring Nightmare
Shahrazad
Sway of the Stars
Tempest Efreet
Time Vault
Time Walk
Timmerian Fiends
Tinker
Upheaval
Worldgorger Dragon
Yawgmoth's Bargain
- Additionally, the following cards may not be used as a General:
Braids, Cabal Minion
- Mulligans are "Partial Paris" (see http://www.dragonhighlander.net/rules.php).
- Points will not be awarded win/lose as in previous constructed leagues but rather according to the rules below.
- Printable version of points awards
- A player claiming a points award must do so before the end of the turn when the condition is met and must indicate to all players that they are claiming the award. Players may also point out points awards for other players. Each award may only be claimed once per game, unless stated otherwise.
-2 Points
Chasm: Destroy or Remove all lands in play through spells or abilities. (This penalty is in the spirit of the rule, and not the letter of the rule, effects that would reset the board for all or most of the players at the table will be awarded this penalty. This can be awarded to the same player more than once per pod.)
-1 Point
Greedy McGreederson: Per extra turn taken. Can be awarded more than once.
+1 Point
123s: Resolve the third spell that’s converted mana cost is the third number in a row. Player A plays Mogg Fanatic (CMC 1) then Vexing Shusher (CMC 2), then Player B resolves Volcanic Fallout (CMC 3) Player B would be awarded this. If Player C then casts Chameleon Colossus, Player C would get an extra point for following this pattern, and each successive spell resolving in an increasing fashion would awarded 1 point.
Better Late Than Never: First player to resolve the second version of a creature already in play. It must be the exact same card as the first (copies and Clones don’t count).
Blackjack: Control two creatures whose total power is exactly 21. May be awarded for a specific creature pair only once per pod (A creature that leaves play and comes back is a different creature).
Block Party: Have a permanent in play or spell present on the stack from each set of any block. The blocks are Ice Age, Invasion, Kamigawa, Lorwyn-Shadowmoor, Masques, Mirage, Mirrodin, Odyssey, Onslaught, Ravnica, Shards of Alara, Tempest, Time Spiral, Urza. (Basic Lands from those sets do not count.)
Copycat: First player to have a spell or permanent copied by an opponent.
Déjà vu: Be the first player to have a card put on top your library from the battlefield, graveyard or the stack by an opponent.
Double Take: First player to control two functionally identical non-token creatures with different names. Creatures must have the same power, toughness, converted mana cost and all abilities (such as Grizzly Bears and Balduvian Bears), but not necessarily color (such as Prodigal Sorcerer and Prodigal Pyromancer). This will awarded only when the stack is empty. (Copies and Clones don’t count).
Edge of Disaster: First player to have fewer than five cards in his or her library.
Enhanced Interrogation Techniques: Cause a creature to be sent to the Graveyard by means of -1/-1 counters.
First Blood: First player to have a creature killed by an opponent. Kill includes destroy, exile, or cause a player to sacrifice the creature. Combat damage doesn’t count. (This can be awarded to multiple people if they all have creatures killed at the same time by the same effect – Wrath of God, Damnation, etc…)
Fourth Times the Charm: Resolve your General 4 times in a single game from the Command Zone.
Generalissimo: Kill a player with General damage. Can be awarded more than once.
Getting to Basics: Control at least 7 Basic Lands.
Good Samaritan: Intentionally cause an opponent to gain 10+ life in one shot (getting your Beacon of Immortality redirected doesn’t count for you, but for the person who redirected it).
Hey, That’s Mine: First player to have a permanent stolen (exchanges don’t count).
Hot Potato: Redirect any portion of non combat damage directed at you to another opponent.
I’m Cool Too: Second player to kill a creature he or she doesn’t control. Kill includes destroy, exile, or cause a player to sacrifice the creature. Combat damage doesn’t count.
I’m Probably Next: Have the lowest life total, which must be lower than 10 when the first player is killed.
Just Enough: Deal exactly lethal non-General damage to a player who is at 7 or more life.
Let’s Do That Again: Save an opponent from taking lethal damage. (This can be through prevention or redirection of damage, whether it be direct or from creatures, or through the use of life gaining spells or abilities. This award can only be earned once per opponent saved, multiple saves of the same opponent by the same person do not count.)
Look at Me: Last person standing in a pod.
Lucky 13: Have a single creature deal exactly 13 combat damage to a player at once. May be awarded for an individual creature only once per pod. (A creature that leaves play and comes back is a different creature).
Overkill: Deal 40+ more damage to a player than is required to kill them.
Salsa Dancer: Cast the fifth spell on a single stack; cannot be awarded in the same stack as Flamenco Dancer.
Start with the Top: Destroy or Exile a Sensei’s Divining Top you don’t control.
Straight: Control at least one creature of five consecutive powers (for example, Mogg Fanatic, Jackal Pup, Mogg Flunkies, Ravenous Baloth, Shivan Dragon). This will be awarded only when the stack is empty. This may only be awarded to an individual player once per pod, although it may be awarded to multiple players.
Taste the Rainbow: Sacrifice five total different creatures in one turn. Of those creatures you must sacrifice a creature for each color of your General. Multicolored creatures can be sacrificed for this, but will have to choose what color they are being sacrificed for.
That Was Rude: First player to have a spell countered by another player’s spell or ability.
What Goes Around: Take control of a permanent that an opponent took control of from another opponent.
+2 Points
Cramped Quarters: Control at least 40 different non-token permanents with the stack empty.
Three’s Not a Crowd: Resolve three different non-land permanents of three different types on the same turn. This may only be awarded to an individual player once per pod, although it may be awarded to multiple players. (Non-land permanent types are Artifact, Creature, Enchantment, and Planeswalker. Resolving a spell that is any combination of permanent types will count as one or the other, not both. Example: Enigma Sphinx is an Artifact Creature; you must choose whether it will count for your Artifact or your Creature for this award.)
You’re Outta Here: Kill a player or being directly responsible for a player’s death. There is the obvious – controlling the source of the damage (whether it’s direct or creatures). This also includes, although is not limited to alternate methods, such as controlling the Howling Mine that makes the player deck himself, or redirecting lethal damage to someone. (Player A plays Fireball, Player B Swerves the Fireball to Player C.) This can be awarded more than once to the same player.
+3 Points
ABCs: Resolve the third spell that starts with a third consecutive letter, one additional point to a player who continues the chain. For example Player A plays Storm Herd, Player B casts Terminate then Unsummon. Player B gets 3 points. Player C then plays Venser and gets 1 Point. Player B then plays Withered Wretch and gets 1 point. Player D casts Wrath of God, therefore breaking the chain.
Flush: Control five non-token creatures of EXACTLY the same color (five Green creatures, or Green and Red creatures, but not three Green and 2 Green and Red). This will be awarded only when the stack is empty. This may only be awarded to an individual player once per pod, although it may be awarded to multiple players.
Flamenco Dancer: Cast the eighth spell on a single stack, cannot be awarded in the same stack as Salsa Dancer.
Straight Flush: Control five creatures of exactly the same color(s) in five consecutive powers. This will be awarded only when the stack is empty. This may only be awarded to an individual player once per pod, although it may be awarded to multiple players.
+4 Points
Bases Loaded: Control a Land, Creature, Enchantment, Artifact, and Planeswalker, while having both a Sorcery and an Instant present on the stack.
Short Version
Views: 53
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by Tom Reeve on
-
You know the official rules are for 100 cards including General, right? Don't really mind either way, just checking. Having 101 of a particular sleeve can also be irritating ;)
-
Permalink Reply by Glenn Goldsworthy on
-
so can herpies
-
-
I guess I won't play my infinate turn deck then. Win the game some points however minus 4000 for the round it's self, actually that kind of sounds like a challange
-
Permalink Reply by Thomas David Baker on
-
@Tom - Changed it. Not sure where I picked that idea up from - I thought I had recently learnt it but perhaps I dreamt it :P
-
-
Can I also request that we use a slightly modified version of the General rule (that I've been having some arguments with Ruling Committee people about).
The only change is as follows;
"Coloured mana symbols which may appear in an EDH deck are restricted to the colours appearing in the General's mana cost."
becomes
"Coloured mana symbols which may appear in an EDH deck are restricted to the colours appearing in mana symbols found on the General."
The only effect of the change is to effectively 'unban' Memnarch, Bosh, Thelon, Rhys and Daughter of Autumn, which under the official rules can in theory be chosen as a General, but then not legally included in their own deck (a state of affairs that I find pretty damn stupid.) It would leave Memnarch as a blue general, Bosh as red, Thelon as black/green, Rhys as black/green and Daughter of Autumn as green/white.
-
Permalink Reply by Dan Barrett on
-
Tom, can you also get them to allow hybrid cards "properly"
It makes no sense that you are not allowed to play Vexing Shusher in your mono-green deck when you can play it for GG.
-
-
@Tom, @Dan - If I get two posts on this thread saying, "agree with Tom"/"agree with Dan" and no nay-sayers then yes.
(Hybrid mana is just one big mistake, really, isn't it?)
-
-
Fair enough. I'll even refrain from posting twice saying 'agree with Tom' ;)
Thomas David Baker said:@Tom, @Dan - If I get two posts on this thread saying, "agree with Tom"/"agree with Dan" and no nay-sayers then yes.
(Hybrid mana is just one big mistake, really, isn't it?)
-
Permalink Reply by Ben Titmarsh on
-
Tom, we don't actually have to submit our entire deck do we? Can we just submit our general? I change my EDH on an almost weekly basis, not to mention to addition of various broken combos for Rome! Plus typing the whole thing out will be painful...
Who's seriously going to meta deck? And if they do, they have 1/100 chance of hitting their card. I'm willing to take that chance.
-
-
can i just say, while the spirit of this is fantastic, keeping track of these things during games is going to be arduous as fuck.
-
-
several things hybrids are 2 colours the same as gold cards so shouldn't be allowed even if you can pay for them.
as for keeping score someone will have to come up with a check card with only a couple of words on them (using a grid is the way forwards), as it stands above some of them will be very complex to describe in a few words, I guess the home is that nobody tries any of these random stuff
© 2024 Created by Thomas David Baker.
Powered by
