Demonic Tutor

Magic: the Gathering in the UK

Players (in turn order):

* Thomas David Baker
Dan Barrett
Tiffany Leek
Gary Lynch
Ross Miles
Kieran Symington
Ben Titmarsh
Paul Young

Thomas David Baker Turn 1.

Rule 301 (Proposal):

Any player may, on their turn, reduce another player's score by any number of points provided they also reduce their own score by this many points.  Their score may not fall below 0 this way.

Please vote on this proposal below.

* Thomas David Baker YES
Dan Barrett YES
Tiffany Leek YES
Gary Lynch YES
Ross Miles YES
Kieran Symington YES
Ben Titmarsh YES
Paul Young NO

(Not adopted.)

Views: 35

Replies are closed for this discussion.

Replies to This Discussion

301

Thomas David Baker PROPOSER
Dan Barrett ?
Tiffany Leek ?
Gary Lynch YES
Ross Miles YES
Kieran Symington YES
Ben Titmarsh ?
Paul Young NO

My score is NOT 5 as previously stated, it is (10 * x) - 10 where x is yet to be determined because not everyone has voted.

302

Thomas David Baker YES
Dan Barrett PROPOSER
Tiffany Leek ?
Gary Lynch ?
Ross Miles ?
Kieran Symington ?
Ben Titmarsh ?
Paul Young ?
YES on 301!
I thought a new post would be started for each proposal. Can we do this in future so we dont end up with 1 long post.

I vote yes on this proposal.

Dan Barrett said:
Dan Barrett Turn 1.

Rule 302 (Proposal):

Any player who votes in favour of another player's rule suggestion receives 1 point if that rule change is adopted.


Vote pls?
301

Thomas David Baker PROPOSER
Dan Barrett YES
Tiffany Leek YES
Gary Lynch YES
Ross Miles YES
Kieran Symington YES
Ben Titmarsh ?
Paul Young NO

My score is NOT 5 as previously stated, it is (10 * x) - 10 where x is yet to be determined because not everyone has voted.

302

Thomas David Baker YES
Dan Barrett PROPOSER
Tiffany Leek YES
Gary Lynch YES
Ross Miles ?
Kieran Symington ?
Ben Titmarsh ?
Paul Young ?
Seems like a good idea. I vote yes.

Dan Barrett said:
Dan Barrett Turn 1.

Rule 302 (Proposal):

Any player who votes in favour of another player's rule suggestion receives 1 point if that rule change is adopted.


Vote pls?
The nomic discussions are hard to get to if you don't use latest ctivity links on the left, they don't appear in the main discussions listing??

Rule 303 (Proposal):

Any player who votes on another player's suggestion within 24 hours of it's proposal receives one (1) point once voting on that suggestion is complete, regardless of whether it is adopted.
I have closed this thread. Each proposal now has its own thread.

Ben T - please let me know your vote on my proposal via email for scoring purposes.

RSS

© 2019   Created by Thomas David Baker.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service